Roundtable 2 READERS · 1 BOOK

A Brief Atlas of Vanished Rivers

by Ines Calloway · History · 2016 · 464 pages

Two readers, one atlas, and a disagreement about whether you should read it front to back.

Genre
History
First published
2016
Pages
464
ISBN
978-1-0000-0003-1

Verdicts at a glance

RNKD average 4 of 5 across 2 ratings — a number that hides the interesting part. Each reader wrote before seeing the others.

TAKE 01
T

Tomasz Wilk

History, nonfiction, the occasional sci-fi. Cares whether a book earns its length.

5 of 5 WOULD RECOMMEND Finished · Spoiler-free

The best kind of history: you finish it and the map in your head is different.

Calloway follows twelve rivers that no longer exist — diverted, drained, built over — and uses each one to explain a city. The chapter on the Fleet is worth the price alone. She has a historian's patience and a journalist's sense of when to stop. Five stars because I've already bought two copies for other people.

TAKE 02
M

Marcus Bell

Business, memoir, big-idea nonfiction. Reads on the train.

3 of 5 DEPENDS Finished · Spoiler-free

How Marcus got the book RNKD provided this reviewer with a copy of the book. No cash payment was made for the review, and the author or publisher had no involvement.

Fascinating in chapters, exhausting as a whole. Read it like a magazine.

Every individual chapter is excellent and I'd hand any one of them to a coworker. But twelve in a row is a lot of drainage. I put it down for a month around river seven and came back happier. Recommend if you dip in and out. Don't try to read it straight through on a commute — I did, and it flattened.

Copy provided by RNKD More from Marcus →

Where they agreed

Both readers call the individual chapters excellent and single out the same one — the Fleet — as the best.

Where they split

Whether to read it straight through. Tomasz did and gives it five. Marcus did and says don't; dip in and out instead.

Summary drafted from the reviews above and checked by an RNKD editor. It adds nothing the readers didn't say. How Roundtables work

Report an error on this page How we review Affiliate disclosure